I have worn the boots three times on rides. The first was on a 20 degree day, the boots really weren't warm enough for that weather. The other two times were warmer and they worked great. I really like the lacing system. very comfortable. would recommend.
I commute to work (5.5 miles) with these and my feet are dry, very comfortable. Feet did sweat when I tried wearing wool socks with them during a 45 deg F day. These are great for cold, wet rides. Would highly recommend
Who doesn't love Boa closures?!
This has been a solid boot for commuting and winter riding. NOTE this is not a waterproof boot.
The fit is on the roomy side which works for me because I prefer thick socks for the extra cushion and warmth.
In the long run, I worry about the reflective surface wearing down...but I'll cross that bridge when it comes.
The only thing that kept this from getting 5 stars is the bizarre inserts...I promptly replaced them. There is a padcushion that presses right into the arch of my foot. It might be ok for some but my foot is on the flatter side and the bump irritated my arches.
Overall, a great shoe and as previously noted, it isn't 100% waterproof but will take care of you just fine. I have a pair of Fasterkatts when I'm in need of a waterproof boot...but you pay the price due to weight.