These shorts look and feel great, and provided great protection at first. But the material connecting the knee pads to the rest of the tights is simply not good enough, as is obvious upon visual inspection: just super thin lycra with a minimal seam. Mine tore on the left knee within the first few rides, during a fairly mundane sort-of crash, separating at the seam where the knee pad meets the rest. I own two pairs of these, since I loved how it keeps the knee pads in place on long rides, but the durability is huge issue and I can't recommend it.
The chamois is oddly large in the front but I forget about after a couple of minutes. The shorts are comfortable and fit under my MTB shorts without issues. I like the extra protection they provide without a lot of bulk. Temperature wise they are comfortable as well.