My first pair of Sidi's and I am impressed with the quality of the shoes. They are at the low cost end of their product line, but the construction is immaculate. I wear US size 11.5 and have a slightly narrow foot. The size 46's fit perfectly. One thing to note, the uppers on these shoes are pretty stiff and will require some break in time. I've only had mine for a couple of weeks, so have not fully broken them in. That's why I've only scored them 4 stars. If they get more supple after more rides, they will be 5 star shoes.
I was pleased that the fit was consistent with that of my higher end Sidi road shoes. It is a great shoe for cool weather riding as there is little ventilation. I ordered the orange and black color and I have to say it is much brighter and more redorange than pictured. Think highway cone orange and not pumpkin. I'm getting used to it and who knows it might keep me from getting mistaken for a deer!
As a year round commuter and wanna-be cyclocross rider in the PNW, I hate shoes with too much venting. My feet are going to get wet, sure, but there is no reason to let in any more moisture than needed. My goal with these was to try out a highly recommended brand and see if they last more than a couple PNW rainy season.
I have narrow feet and the fit of these is great (46). I don't have to tighten them way down to keep my feet from sliding side to side.
There is no flex in the soles, walking is less comfortable than my previous Shimano mt-80s. Tred is also smaller and less stable for walking.
The most significant difference between these and the domiators is that these don't have carbon soles. Saying that though it's still an extraordinary pair of shoes. The walking and performance is still better than other mountain bike shoes in it's class, I've biked roughly a thousand miles on these and they're still comfortable and reliable.