There are two versions of this tool, one with the guide pin and one without. I was recommended the version with the guide pin by some friends, and definitely agree that it's worth the small upcharge. Easy to align and stays secure.
I used this tool to remove and install cassettes on both my road and mountain bikes. I like the guide pin because it helps in making sure attachment to lockring is correct. This tool is a must for the home mechanic - the ability to remove cassettes is necessary for proper cleaning and maintenance
It aligns and seats well. It is better than the old one I can't find without the pin. It's been effective on expensive and very, very cheap cassettes. It's machined well, but won't blow you away. For that I'm still not going call it a an awesome value.
Can't perform the procedure without this tool, which pays for itself with the very first use. Seems durable enough for years of use in the future, even if used at a pro shop.
If you are serious about cycling, you need this tool as it is the only way to remove a cassette from your wheel. Don't pay a shop to do this simple task for you, get this cassette tool, and a chain whip and you are all set!
I have a couple of these from various manufacturers. This is adequate for the job, and performs as intended. What can you say? Pretty much a specialized socket without the ability to be connected directly to a ratchet.